Collision at Sea

Alex F

Well-Known Member
Nov 14, 2006
9,166
Miami / Ft Lauderdale
Boat Info
2005 420DB with AB 11 DLX Tender, Raymarine Electronics (2x12" MFDs) with Vesper AIS
Engines
Cummins 450Cs, 9KW Onan Generator, 40HP Yamaha for tender.
I was doing some research and stumbled in to this story. By all means it’s a big time a wake up call with some lessons to be learned, so I thought it would be a good idea to share this story with you guys.

Be safe out there and have all necessary knowledge and tools to handle a disaster.

Alex.
--------------------------------------------------
The following content is copied from another source and writen by the boat owner who survived the collision.

Our boat, the Glory Days, is a 30’ Pursuit Express, my wife Carol and I were traveling north from Hilton Head SC back to Seabrook in the ocean about 12 miles east of Port Royal Sound. I was cruising at 23 knots and the ocean was very calm, maybe one foot chop with the wind out of the SE. All of a sudden it felt like we had run aground but we were in 50 feet of water. There was a loud bang and the boat shuttered violently, Carol was thrown through the air and landed in the cockpit. I throttled back immediately and looked back to see what we hit but I couldn’t see anything.



I opened the engine day hatch and it looked like water was shooting in from a fire hose. I immediately called in a mayday on channel 16 and raised the coast guard station on Tybee Island . I relayed my lat/lon position and they dispatched a helo. I couldn’t hear them too well but apparently they had good reception from me. At this point I still had forward steerage way and I pointed the boat toward shore.



I went into the cabin to get the life raft and EPIRB and brought them both out on deck. As I looked up I saw a whale surface about 50 yards from the boat. The whale was at least as big as the boat, the fluke seemed over 8 feet in diameter and I saw blood coming out of the top of the whale. Carol was getting the life jackets and I called her to the cockpit and she saw it too. The coast guard helo later identified it as a right whale and it was swimming when they saw it so I hope it survived the collision.



We put on life jackets and attached the tether from the life raft to the stern cleat and got it ready to deploy. It took about 10 minutes for the coast guard helo to reach us. I asked the coast guard if we should deploy the raft or wait and they suggested waiting because they were directing a fishing boat that was in the area to assist us. About 10 minutes later a 25 foot center console arrived on seen, it was a fishing charter called Big Time and Carol moved to this boat. Many thanks to Captain Jason Dubose for staying with us.



By this time water had risen to about two feet in the engine room, the battery was submerged and the port engine had quit. The water was about one foot in the cabin. The starboard engine was still running and I shut it down because the high water alarm was sounding and it looked like it would be submerged soon. At this point I transferred some gear to the Big Time because I expected the Glory Days would sink soon.



The coast guard helo indicated that they had a boat in route coming out of Port Royal sound, we were lucky that they happened to be on patrol in that area. They arrived on site about 20 minutes after the Big Time got there. Three coastguards’ men transferred to Glory Days, one was an engineer named Ryan. He lifted the hatches and looked around for the leak. After a few minutes he noted that the port shaft was no longer connected to the transmission and the water was coming in fast from the hole in the hull. He then went to work plugging the hole. I had several wooden bungs and we cut one down to fit the hole (I had a saw on board).



At this point both bilge pumps were still running and we had two hand pumps but we were not keeping up with the flow of water which was about 2 feet in the engine room and cabin. Ryan was having a hard time fixing the leak because he was half in the water in the bilge and was getting zapped by the current running through everything he touched.



The helo had gone back to base to pick up a portable pump and air dropped it to another coast guard vessel that arrived on scene, this was a 41 footer out of Tybee station. This vessel transferred the pump to the Glory Days and once they got it working it evacuated the water quickly. At the same time Ryan was able to slow the leak by shoving rags and the bung into the hole. He was amazing and stuck with it. Once the leak stopped and the water was pumped out we checked the fluids in the starboard engine and restarted it. We were able to come in on one engine but Ryan and Jon both stayed with me (and the pump) in case plug in the shaft hole didn’t hold.



The coast guard 25 footer now had Carol aboard and escorted us for about a 21/2 hour ride to Skull Creek Marina. When we got there they were ready to pull the boat and immediately got it into the lift. When it came out the port shaft and prop were missing, the strut was bent at a 90 degree angle to the right, and the port rudder was bent at a 45 degree angle back. There are deep gauges in the keel where the prop spun through the fiberglass and deep cuts in the port rudder. The violence of the impact was amazing. We estimate that the whale was heading for us and surfaced head first into the port running gear since everything seemed pushed back and to the side.



Quite a day! It is certainly a wake up call that anything can happen at any time in the ocean.

I was well equipped with safety gear. Although a life raft, epirb, off shore jackets, hand held vhf and gps adds up in cost – it seemed really cheap last Tuesday when we were taking water and 10 minutes from sinking. If this had happened in the Gulf Stream chances are not as good that the Coast Guard would be on station as quickly and we would have ended up in the raft. “Don’t leave home without one!”



The Glory Days is severely damaged and may be a total loss but that is in the hands of the insurance company. Carol and I are fine and I hope the whale is too!
 
Oh great, this summer we are planning our trip to New York and of course we will be ocean going. Now you got me freaked out… Sounds like the story came right out of the movie “Jaws” “We’re going to need a bigger boat!”

PS. Not going to mention this to the Admiral!
 
Oh great, this summer we are planning our trip to New York and of course we will be ocean going. Now you got me freaked out… Sounds like the story came right out of the movie “Jaws” “We’re going to need a bigger boat!”

PS. Not going to mention this to the Admiral!

Bill,

I feel the same way, b/c I'm planning to explore Long Island area next summer. I'll be in middle of no where for few hours while crossing over from NJ. You'll be travelling with a group, so you've got yourself a pretty good safeguards.

My intention was to share the story just as a reminder to all. Stay alert, be prepared, maintain control and don't freak out. You are the captains!

P.S.
DO NOT share the story with admiral, unless you know she can take it. Just educate her using general examples.
 
Last edited:
What an experience! What should have been an eazy run turns nasty in a hurry. Preparation is the key, glad to see this guy was fully prepared. It could have been alot worse. I think I'll be double checking my gear this year!
 
Bill,

I feel the same way, b/c I'm planning to explore Long Island area next summer. I'll be in middle of no where for few hours while crossing over from NJ. You'll be travelling with a group, so you've got yourself a pretty good safeguards.

My intention was to share the story just as a reminder to all. Stay alert, be prepared, maintain control and don't freak out. You are the captains!

P.S.
DO NOT share the story with admiral, unless you know she can take it. Just educate her using general examples.


Yea we will be with a group, I'm not sure I would take on this adventure by myself anyway. Besides I was just kidd’n. Anyway you are right about posting it to make a point of being prepared for anything that could happen out there. :thumbsup:

Anyone know the odds of being hit by a whale? :grin:
 
Did they have their depth sounder on? If yes that is probaly why the whale was confused and was hit it. So I have been told. Any one with information on the effect of depth sounder on marine creatures? I always turn mine off once we are in open water.
 
Did they have their depth sounder on? If yes that is probaly why the whale was confused and was hit it. So I have been told. Any one with information on the effect of depth sounder on marine creatures? I always turn mine off once we are in open water.

Interesting point, but I would think that most boats don't have the switch to turn of the transducer. If it's powered only when a depthfinder is on, sure you've got an option to turn if off. But, how would this be possible with multi functional displays? Also, boats that equiped with SmartCraft, the transducer is feeding the SC directly (providing depth reading to the Tachs), so there's no possible way that I can think of to have my trancducer off.

I would think that if the theory is possible we would have many more collisions due to the issue of depth/speed transducers/sounders confusing marine creatures. This is just my opinion, but I'd love to learn more on this topic.
 
Glad you are both safe. That's a story you will be telling for quite some time. God Bless.
 
Scott - even though this "Then again, the odds on me frightening a whale in the Great Lakes is pretty remote" may not happen you may need to issue hard hats (and ball bats) to fend off the asian carp!
 
Glad you are both safe. That's a story you will be telling for quite some time. God Bless.

Thanks, but just to clarify this didn't happen to me, thank GOD. I got this from another board and just wanted to share the story with my CSR fellow boaters.

...I am a little skeptical that a single boats' transducer can have any effect what so ever on a whaler, but then again I am not a marine biologist either. The problem I see with turning the transudcer/depth finder off in deep water is what if you forget to turn it back on again? Unlikely, but it could happen, particularly if you get used to not including the instrument in your visual scan (because it's off).

Additionally, I use my finder for navigating. With a compass, a good chart and a depth finder, you can navigate pretty well in the Great Lakes....

I'm with you on this one.
 
Last edited:
The last time I was out the Coast Guard put out a safety broadcast to be aware of a Pilot Whale which had been spotted off the Outer Banks. This story is a reminder to be aware of your surroundings and to make sure you are as prepared as reasonably possible. I'm reminded again to get an assortment of bungs to fill in holes.
 
This story is a reminder to be aware of your surroundings and to make sure you are as prepared as reasonably possible.

I hope folks that constantly run on plane at night read this story as well. Hopefully, it'll slow them down a little.
 
Wow. Every day is an adventure if you're prepared and a disaster if you're not.

Words to live by.

I few things I thought about while reading this;

1) Being prepared is the difference between life and death. GPS, radios, floatation gear.

2) Being *well* prepared means that not only do you live. . .but you bring the boat home! Note the Bungs and Saw references in the story. The coast guard Engineer saved the boat because he had the supplies to work with.

3) Coast Guard: WAY TO GO! Above and beyond. In my mind, saving the boat not only *saves the boat*, but prevents an environmental problem and a Nav hazard (where is that pic of a boat demonstrating "basic floation"? The one where you see a boat 95% submerged with just a little bit of bow above the waves. . .). Win/Win/Win.

4) Hmmm. Life raft in the cabin? Is that the best place for it? I guess there might not be much room for such a thing in the cockpit area on a boat that size?

5) This is why you have insurance. At no point was there a question of risking life and limb (once the first rescue craft arrived). At no point was "financial loss" influencing thinking. Hopefully, all this boat needs is some glass work and a repower. Worst case. . consider this an opportunity to upgrade!

6) Note to self: Definately don't show this to the Admiral.

7) Note to self: Consider upgrading radio to one with GPS Interface. (example: http://www.boemarine.com/Products/010-00755-00/Default.aspx <= Yes, this is from the website of the Site Sponsor)
 
Alex, Just make sure that you pay your insurance premiums before going on Ocean trips... With the price of boats today, they are worth more on the bottom of the ocean...
 
Alex, Just make sure that you pay your insurance premiums before going on Ocean trips... With the price of boats today, they are worth more on the bottom of the ocean...

:lol: I hear you Rod, but this is not my way to upgrade :lol:

I wander how long did it take for the family who was involved to overcome the emotional stress and for admiral to accept to get back in to boating.
 
What an incredible story indeed. I agree that being prepared helps you navigate a crisis situation. This past summer, i found us going through the emergency procedures, with us preparing to abandon ship just in case we were sinking. Within 90 seconds, we had gone through all the steps we needed to take just in case my worst fears were realized. We got the ditch bag ready, spare flare kit, hand held radio, radio'd our coordinates, cell phones in waterproof ziplock bags, and the dinghy prepped in case we needed to transfer to it. We were already wearing PFD's. There was a lot to do when i realized we were in trouble, but we rehearsed it many times before and were ready for it when something happened. As it turned out, we had only broken a prop shaft OUTSIDE the boat and weren't taking on water. But i didnt want to waste 1 second finding out what was wrong before we started our emergency procedures. I was happy that we were prepared for the worst case scenario and THEN started to troubleshoot. If we did it the other way around, and we were taking on water, scrambling to do the emergency list at that point would be more chaotic than it turned out to be! Talk about an adrenaline rush...
 

Forum statistics

Threads
113,253
Messages
1,429,338
Members
61,128
Latest member
MinecraftRuSwilm
Back
Top