Boat loan – what are you thinking?

Presentation

Well-Known Member
TECHNICAL Contributor
Oct 3, 2006
4,404
Wisconsin - Winnebago Pool chain of lakes
Boat Info
280 Sundancer, Westerbeke MPV generator
Engines
twin 5.0's w/BIII drives
My philosophy of loans;

Your primary residence? Sure. A history of long term appreciation, tax deductible interest and you need to live somewhere.

Student loans? I can see investing in you. Taking loans to allow a better future for yourself makes sense.

Non-cosmetic surgery? Of course. Need that to live.

If you are not a business owner I am done. No other reason makes sense to me.

At 40 we have everything paid off. The various tax-incentive retirement programs have been maxed out for more then a decade and a half. My wife and I paid our own way thru college yet all three of our kids have a college savings plan in place financed by us. Then with the money left over we go on vacations, buy boats and have fun. I never considered taking out a loan for our boat.

Not long ago a friend lost his job. His wife confided in my wife that they had less then $300 in savings. She was trembling and in tears. As it turned out he found another job and his first paycheck was exactly 2 weeks after is last severance check. He never missed a beat. He then thru a party to celebrate his new job. At the party he said “Hey Doug – come look at my new toy.†We went to the garage and he showed me the mother of walk behind snow blowers. The thing was big. It had tracks in place of wheels, headlight, a front, top and 2 side enclosure for the operator. So I asked him how he was able to afford it. He said he could not turn it down since he does not have to even start making payments for a year. Payments??!? On a snow blower? What the……???

I have a brother that has made his retirement plan clear. He plans to smoke (a bad habit that I will never do) 4 to 5 packs a day until he dies. He actually plans to die rather then save for retirement.

My brother-in-law once bragged to me about how big his cable bill is each month. This is another thing I don’t understand. We get 13, that’s thirteen boadcast channels, in perfect clarity due to them being digital, and we get them for free. His cable bill is well over $100 month. His daughter just graduated high school. She wanted to go to college. With mortgage payments on their home, cars, credit card payment all taking every bit of income they have, none going to retirement, he has pushed her into the military. Now I have nothing against the military. I hold our military members in high regard. My issue is she had no interest in this. He pushed her into joining. I honesty fear she will get killed and the reason will be so her dad could drive a new big SUV, have a deluxe cable TV package and otherwise poor money management habits.

This brings me to wonder about people that take out boat loans. If they are maxing out retirement plants, college savings for the kids if they have them and their over-all financial situation is in good order I guess its not a big deal. However I have read on this very board that a member is waiting to hear back ‘if’ his loan will go thru. If there is any question that the loan may not get approved then there can be no chance the person’s financial household is in order. That being the case what is the person going to do when they are 67 years old and Social Security and Medicare is cut back to a fraction of its current level and has little or no savings?

We enjoy our 280 Sundancer. I thought it was a big boat until a member recently told me its just a little 280. However we can afford this boat. This means that we can afford this boat AND keep our families financial house in order. From a pure financial perspective, if we were to rob our savings, mortgage the house, etcetera we would have enough money to buy the biggest boat that Sea Ray offers. we could make the payment. But……….we could not do this with out damaging our families financials.

An alternative exists. We purchased a smaller, older boat we can afford.

So….why do people take out a loan on a boat?
 
I asked the question on this site some time ago. I was trying to figure out why anyone would get a loan on a boat. To us, adding a loan payment to fuel and maintenance seemed crazy. I believe one of the responses was something to the effect that since it qualifies as a second home, the interest is deductible. I'm with you on the financial responsibility thing. We have two homes in Florida, one we rent out, the other we live in. We have one mortgage, two cars, no car loans, one boat, no boat loan. We pay our credit cards in full every month. We don't pay for mooring because we live on the water and the boat is at our dock. (As for cable, guilty. Gotta have BBC America.) But as to the issue of loans on a boat, deductible or not, seems to me the loan is likely to be around longer than the boat and that's kinda scary. Our solution was to pay cash for an older boat; one we could afford. Oh we drool over new SeaRays and our neighbor's 48' Bayliner makes our 250 look like a tender but we can afford what we have. Having said all that, I wonder how many boats would be out there on the water if boat loans didn't exist? The bottom line is that everybody has to make up their own mind whether or not a boat loan make sense. For us it doesn't. For others it might.

-Chazaroo
 
Presentation:

You are un-american! How can you spout such anti-American propaganda on a red-blooded, flag waving American message board? Did you graduate from a Soviet propaganda school? I bet you have a portrait of Mao in your living room. Have you stopped beating your wife?

:grin: :grin: :grin:

On a more serious note, I see two types of people in the country today; those who run their finances the way that you run them, and those that view money as something to be spent.

And when you spend money, you have no savings. And when you have no savings, you finance your house. Then you finance your car. Then your vacation. And ultimately you finance your snow blower. Why not? No payments for a year. Only $30 a month!

After all. . .. you might be *dead* by the time the payments are due. In that case -> you win!

There are a few interesting things about all this
  • First, by not financing, you don't have the burden of finance charges. Don't let anyone kid you -> if they weren't making money from the financing, you wouldn't offer you a loan. Not financing means you can spend 7% more on the car.

    Second; You know, you could *really* die before retirement. In which case, your quality of life could really be better!

    Third; The US credit market is on the brink. You can lose 20% of your life savings next week. No kidding. We are *on the verge*. And the "fixed income" funds are not entirely safe in this particular crisis. Seriously. Take a look at what happened to the US equity markets between 2000 and 2002. Dow went from 12,000 to 7,000. I lost 40% of my savings in that time. Of course, with the Dow at 13,500 I now have all that money back and then some. But one must recognize that investing is not a zero risk game. We are all vulnerable not just to the markets, but to Fraud and Radical Taxation. Having $1,000,000 in the bank today does not ensure a good retirement (although it *really* improves the odds)

    Fourth: Having a good financial picture has important side benefits. Back in 2002, my job was in danger. Being out of debt, having a sum of money in the bank (despite the market losses), I was able to walk into work on THE day of layoffs with a smile on my face. Loose my job? That means I spend a week putting out a resume, and then take a few weeks off and enjoy the summer! I would not have even reduced my spending for the first six monthes.

    Fifth: Unplanned medical expenses. 'nough said.

So in my mind, it boils down to a lifestyle choice.

Live on the edge, or live secure. Living on the Edge means you have cooler toys, and you might enjoy life a bit more. Living secure means you have the CHOICE to go to the edge, and means you can smile in the face of financial adversity. Maybe a bit less fun, but you don't have to worry if you suddenly have a $2500 car repair bill.

Life is not easy :huh:
 
Presentation said:
From a pure financial perspective, if we were to rob our savings, mortgage the house, etcetera we would have enough money to buy the biggest boat that Sea Ray offers. we could make the payment. But……….we could not do this with out damaging our families financials.

An alternative exists. We purchased a smaller, older boat we can afford.

So….why do people take out a loan on a boat?

Congratulations for you, you'll probably go to your maker with all your "financials" in order. And your prize is??
Financial security is one aspect of an adult life but it has nothing whatever to do with a happy adult life. Judging, or even questioning anothers reasons for burdening themselves for the pursuit of their own happiness is presumptuous and rude. The financial reasons you question about this boards member waiting for an answer on his loan are quite frankly none of your business.
 
And another thing! We will never get to the point where we have to finance a snow blower...We live in Florida. :smt043 :smt043 :smt043

Chazaroo
 
:smt014 Oh. . . I can see this is going to be a hot button topic. :smt014

There is one aspect to loans in general I do not understand. People refer to "boat loans" and "car loans". People talk about "being upside down" on the loans. In my mind, unless you plan to default, a loan is a loan. The value of the collateral (house, boat or car) is irrelevant. Unless you default, you are paying it back.

If you take a $500,000 mortgage on a $700,000 house; you have just committed to paying back a $500,000 loan. That $3300 monthly payment will be with you for 30 years regardless if you have a job, a wife, on kid or five kids.

So if you take a loan. . .you need to really think about WHAT you are doing with the money you borrow. Buying crack with it would be a *bad* choice. Buying stock equities may not be a bright choice either. You just have to be careful.

- - - - - - - - -

A word on the tax break: Watch out. That "tax break" can go away. Ever hear of AMT? (Alternative Minimum Tax). AMT is not indexed to inflation -> Every year, more people hit the threshold where deductions stop mattering. Over 20 years, you watch and you will find that EVERYONES's deductions will be capped.

Also, TODAY the tax code allows a mortgage deduction on all homes. Elect a Democrat president, with a Democrat congress, and the deduction for a second home is likely to VANISH. Maybe even the deduction for the primary home. And the democrats are the party that has proven fiscal responsibility in the last 20 years.
 
If you truly are interested in maximizing your security, and enjoying life while getting there, and you are not yet subject to the AMT, then it's hard to justify not taking out a loan on your boat. I'm totally against being upside down on anything. I'm totally against considering default as a solution to anything - pull your own damn weight.

All that being said, putting 10-20% down on a used boat, taking out a reasonable loan (< 7% or so), doubling principle on long-term loans (or as required to not get upside down), writing off the interest, and investing the rest wisely is just plain smart business. As head of household, most of us are small business owners/managers. Paying cash is a very safe, stable, conservative non-investment manner of operations management (with those dollars, anyway). Burying it in the back yard is a very sure way of saving money - money eaten away by grubs AND inflation.

Putting it in the bank is safer, yet not totally secure either. Life is about risk and risk management. A good manager takes reasonable risks, accepts moderate gains, and covers him/herself in the event the unexpected occurs. Each must decide how much risk they are willing to accept. If you own a boat, you've already decided to lose money, but look at the gain.

My wife and I have spent 2 nights per week on the boat for over a month now, and the kids have joined us on average 1 night per 2 weeks (they're getting older). We are getting wwwwwwwwwwwaaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy more use out our 340 than 10 years of owning a 250. In many ways, we get wwwwwwaaaaayyyyyy more out of our boating dollar. It's all about choice. Make smart decisions. If you own a boat, and can't afford to pay cash for it, make sure you're getting your money's worth out of it. And for God's sake, don't fall prey to 2-foot itis. Get the right boat and enjoy it for years and years. Our 250 was paid off 4 or 5 years before we moved up. In my opinion, that's the way to go.

If things go as planned, we may move up from this one a little earlier than before, but just to get diesels and more range for travel. The 340 is plenty of boat for 2.
 
Life is short, period. At 43, I've already outlived my father.

Thirteen years ago, I nearly lost my wife to cancer.

I'm with jg300da on this one. Who are you to judge us?

We're not irresponsable, in fact we have excellent credit. We could afford more boat, but that would run us out of our comfort zone. We have decent retirement plan and good stable jobs.

That said, we knew within months of owning our 260DA it was too small for the type of boating we've come to enjoy most. Does that make us snobs? :smt017 Did we finance the 320? You betcha. Our son is 13 - it won't be long before he is out on his own. Boating is something we do together as a family. We've done the math, know our limits, and to us, the cost is worth it.

And that's about all I'm going to say about this.

-CJ
 
There are a few reasons to take a loan on a boat, but to me, the first that comes to mind is "why use your money, when you can use someone else's"....If my well invested money is making enough to pay the loan (long term here...not sweating over market adjustments), then why pull out the prinicipal....just pull out the profit. Heck, that's why it's there....not just to watch it grow....it's there to use...
 
Hampton said:
Life is about risk and risk management. A good manager tasks reasonable risks, accepts moderate gains, and covers him/herself in the event the unexpected occurs. Each must decide how much risk they are willing to accept. If you own a boat, you've already decided to lose money, but look at the gain.

Just got done taking a test for my CRM on Analysis of Risk. One of the professors said if you do not get anything else out of this class get this, it is better to float on someone elses money than to have someone else float on you. Time value of money and making it work for you.

It is a difference in choice. Everyone has different things that make them happy. What you have to know is what makes you happy and figure out a way to enjoy what makes you happy without risking your families livelihood.

Here's to everyone reaching their financial goals while living happy at the same time.

Wesley
 
I admire those who are 100% debt free, and would like to be there myself someday. There are reasons people achieve this, be it through hard work, discipline, inheritance, marriage, good luck or a combination of the above.

Presentation: I don't know you. If you worked hard for everything you have, you have my utmost respect, but may still need to work on being humble. For the rest of us: We're here because we like our Sea Rays, so if you have a loan, more power to you if you are responsible about the way you manage your finances and keep the economy going.
 
As I recall, we paid roughly 25% cash toward our latest boat and financed the balance. This means I'm roughly 25% as good a person as you organized, smart, cash-centric, cool people. You folks probably have more beautiful family members than I do too. You can rest assured that I'll strive to be a better person moving forward. :smt015
 
thunderbird1 said:
As I recall, we paid roughly 25% cash toward our latest boat and financed the balance. This means I'm roughly 25% as good a person as you organized, smart, cash-centric, cool people. You folks probably have more beautiful family members than I do too. You can rest assured that I'll strive to be a better person moving forward. :smt015

Now that's funny!
 
I thought joining CSR would allow me to make friends who enjoy Sea Ray boating; share some knowledge, and learn a great deal, but lately these "threads" have nothing to do with either. If you're interested in preaching I'm sure there is a site for that you can go to but it doesn't seem appropriate here.
 
Presentation,

I dont know if you realize that not eveyone was dealt the hand you were delt. Yes we would all love to be in your shoes.. but this is a human world and there is diversity. some people are born into money and some marry into money. Some people have money and marry into a non money family, which in turn puts financial stress on the one who brings home the bread and butter. Im happy that you are fully paid off but seriously who the hell cares? God bless you seriously in no disrespect. Its just plain stupid to ask "why someone would take out a boat loan" If your so educated you would come to the conclusion that some people want something and cant afford to pay if off all at once! Thats why they make LOANS. Please dont take this the wrong way i mean no disrespect, actually i admire you but its pretty simple why people take out loans. I in fact took out a loan on my little whimpy 185, WHy you might ask? well i just in plain english didnt have the money out right. whats so hard to understand? I own my own buisness, married, kids, and own a home. But some people dont run into the great oppertunities that you might have run into in your life. Hell tomorrow i might gain a million dollar a year floor contract and pay off my boat tomorrow. That would be great but im not gonna go pay off my boat then ask "why do people take loans on a boat when i can pay mine off".. Simple some people have the money and some dont.

-c rock
 

Forum statistics

Threads
113,177
Messages
1,427,996
Members
61,086
Latest member
MrWebster
Back
Top