Should I go? A life altering experience.

dmcb

New Member
Jan 7, 2010
135
Mich/summer Fla./winter
Boat Info
3870.
I have had 3 Sea Rays. Does that count?
Engines
Twin Hino diesels
A lesson story that forever changed my boating.
I boat on the Great Lakes. Mostly Lake Huron even though I now live on Lake Superior.
This happened in the mid 70's.
We left Tobermory Ontario on a course for Saginaw Bay, our dock was at Bay Port, Michigan.
We had waited for good weather as the previous year we caught rough weather and didn't want a repeat of that.
Ha, we though it was rough weather.
At that time the only weather was the Mafor which gave a broadcast every 6 hours. Miss it and wait another 6 hours.
6:00 pm forecast was 0-10 variable winds and clear.
We left at 7:00 pm.
Lake was flat as a floor.
By 9:00 it was getting rough but I thought the waters had not calmed from the previous bad weather.
Not so. It kept building and building.
The bridge of that 46' Chris was 13' off the water, the moon was out and looking up, all I could see was water.
The wind was blowing so hard it drove water off the tops of the waves in almost a solid sheet of water. Wipers were useless.
I need to mention these were Great Lakes waves. Nothing like ocean waves. They are shorter together and steep although as they built, I could actually go up and down them much like an ocean wave.
As they got larger it was actually easier to ride.
Well easy and those seas really don't go together.
We couldn't go back. The markers were floating cans that would be under water in those seas and we would never find them in the dark, even with radar.
Of course no GPS in those days. Compass only.
And the midnight Mafor was the same, 0-10 variable and clear.
I was towing a 14' McKee with a 55hp outboard. The line broke about 3:00 am.
I did manage to get it using a line we used to tie it to a dock.
It was riding well and at the time I wasn't sure of the one I was in and didn't want to lose that safety net.
Then I buried the bow going down a wave. I had a 9' Boston Whaler on the front deck and it washed it loose. but it was still there. Opened a salon door and actually got a line across the bow and in the other salon door but I knew it wasn't good.
Going on the deck was impossible.
A while later I buried the bow again and washed it off but there was still a line attached to the bow and it was being towed along side. Tied another line to it, cut the bow line and paid it back to the back and towed it also.
What I didn't know was the anchor which sat in chocks had come loose and was just laying on the deck.
If it had gone over and the line got in the props, that would have been it for us.
But somehow it just stayed there and was just laying on the deck when we got in.
It was the last time I buried the bow. Another and it surly would have gone over.
Ran auto pilot. I thought I should take the wheel but I couldn't hold it as well as the auto pilot.
I didn't even sit at the helm. It was just to rough.
Couldn't see anyway.
The 6 AM Mafor now said gale warnings. Stay off fishing piers.
When we got into Saginaw Bay something happened and both tow lines broke. The Bay gave some shelter and it wasn't as rough and we managed to reattach both boats.
I lifted the hatch to look at the engines and the bilge was full of water and the shafts were throwing water.
Now that was panic time.
I looked at the bilge pump and a dish rag was wrapped around it. Pop bottles were in the bilge. Out of the cupboards somehow.
It was the first I was able to look at the bilge.
Finally got it pumped out with the help of a large hand pump that was factory installed.
That was a darn good pump. Almost as good as wet feet and a pail.
But we made it.
The Coast Guard flew over us at daylight. Circled a few times. I waved. They left.
They closed the Mackinaw bridge that night. On of the few times it was completely closed in the 50 or so years it has been there.
In all 17 hours of this.
That night tempers my advise now. If I had not had what I thought was rough weather experience I believe things would have been different. I knew the boat, I knew myself, and it really helped.
I see posts from time to time advising a new boater in a new used boat they know nothing about to take an off shore trip, bringing it home or just making a crossing.
I know the unexpected can happen, it can be severe, and you need some experience along with a boat you can trust to cope.
I don't suggest you not go. My advise is conservative however.
I suggest you go out in not so good seas in a controlled condition. Go out and get the feel of your boat and yourself. Increase the experience but keep it close to safety.
You cannot trade that experience for anything when the day comes you need it.
And if you venture out that day will come.
Be sure you are prepared for it.
Doug
 
Last edited:
Interesting read - thanks Doug, and welcome.

I have the T-shirt too, won on a run from Killarney to Gore Bay. It was the only time during my lifetime of boating that I thought we could lose the boat. She was taking her maximum. At one point I altered course to follow a large motoryacht. Unfortunately, I couldn't tell from the distance that her threshold was much lower than our own. She was rolling violently and ended up following US. Like your story, it began with clear skies and perfectly calm seas. You just can't trust a Great Lake!
 
Great post.

Funny that my "T-Shirt" also came on a run to Gore Bay this time though, from the Benjamins 3 years ago. Nothing like DCMB's experience, but 45 Knot sustained winds and 12 - 14 foot short chop waves. The boat and crew were ar the limit. When we sold that boat last year, the survey uncovered a stress crack in the hull, that I can only think came from that day!
 
The North Channel in its way is like the perfect storm.
Runs East/West with West prevailing winds. Broken up with islands.
It is an area to use extreme caution.
We have about 50 miles of it that is open from the St Marys River to get to protected waters and of course our return.
I watch the weather carefully. I don't want an unexpected North Channel experience. Have that shirt also.
Our first visit to the area was 1963 from Saginaw Bay.
We have seen our share.
Doug
 
Three years ago...? Sounds familiar, do you know the date?My experience was July 4, '06. The next week, the winds got even stronger and blew this chartered trawler over in a cove near the Clapperton Channel:

clapptertontrawler.jpg


I was home by then, but it was sobering to see these pictures.

The Gore Bay harbormaster was awesome. He took the conditions into account when assigning the wells, so after the most stressful run of my life, I didn't have to contend with a nasty docking situation. (and some people don't like to tip...!?)
 
Last edited:
Ya I rode out that storm in Baie Fine. Trees fell around us.
A salvage operation from Sault Ste. Marie lifted that trawler. It cost $100,000 and the boat sold for $25,000.
It blew down 3 boat storage buildings at Harbor View Marine in Little Current. Several floating docks at Killarney broke loose with boats attached.
Doug
 
We were stuck in the middle of a high wind storm years ago. The swell was already 8' to 10' and we had gale force winds hit suddenly and rode through the middle of the "Potato Patch" just outside of the Golden Gate. We thought we were out far enough but didn't get out of it. 20' waves breaking over the top of a 32' Chris Craft then....both engines stopped! The captain pushed me aside, lifted the hatch to MANUALLY switch tanks! Needless to say if we turned and got hit broadside we were done for.

I NEVER want to go through anything like that again!!!!!!!!! :wow:

http://wikimapia.org/2387010/Potato-Patch-Shoal
 
Hey Roller, was your experience in the 400? Obviously I'd like some more details on how she handled it. And NOT because I want to experience it for myself!
 
About that trawler. What I heard is he stern anchored with the transom door open.
I bet that owner was so glad he put his boat in the charter fleet. :smt089
Doug
 
Skuza, yes, it was in the 400, and she did well to get us and herself through it without damage.

My shoulder was sore for days from near constant adjustments of the throttle. I had adjusted the windlass to prevent it letting go of the chain (which happens at the worst times). But I didn't lock the dogs on the fwd hatch. With thousands of gallons of Lake Huron slamming against it, I was really regretting not being prepared. It held, but I didn't need the extra stress of imagining what would happen if that hatch opened.

We also hadn't closed the companionway, and no-one would let go of the grabrails to close it. The carpet was wet 1/3 of the way into the salon from the waves leaking through the eisin. We had to go find the toaster. It had escaped from the galley cupboard and had made it's way into the corner of the midcabin berth.

The TV, subwoofer, DVD player etc had all jumped for freedom, but that's my fault. I've since secured that setup. BTW, I'm still looking forward to hearing details of your new TV installation.
 
Skuza, yes, it was in the 400, and she did well to get us and herself through it without damage.

My shoulder was sore for days from near constant adjustments of the throttle. I had adjusted the windlass to prevent it letting go of the chain (which happens at the worst times). But I didn't lock the dogs on the fwd hatch. With thousands of gallons of Lake Huron slamming against it, I was really regretting not being prepared. It held, but I didn't need the extra stress of imagining what would happen if that hatch opened.

We also hadn't closed the companionway, and no-one would let go of the grabrails to close it. The carpet was wet 1/3 of the way into the salon from the waves leaking through the eisin. We had to go find the toaster. It had escaped from the galley cupboard and had made it's way into the corner of the midcabin berth.

The TV, subwoofer, DVD player etc had all jumped for freedom, but that's my fault. I've since secured that setup. BTW, I'm still looking forward to hearing details of your new TV installation.
You earned the shirt. I enjoy your colorful expressions but I can picture your experience.
There was another boat following us the night of my story. The waves smashed his cabin window and they had to stuff a mattress in the hole to keep the water out. He had 7 kids aboard and never left the wheel for 17 hours. My trip was a piece of cake compared to his.
Doug
 
The North Channel in its way is like the perfect storm.
Runs East/West with West prevailing winds. Broken up with islands.
It is an area to use extreme caution.
Doug


Sounds like the St Lawrence at lake Ontario. I got my T-shirt there but in an 18' bowrider on a trip to Kingston Ontario. I truly thought we were going to sink that day in 6'+ river chop. Did you know that even with hundreds of gallons of water rushing at your face, when your eyelids are peeled open your eyeballs WILL stop the water from reaching your brain? It's like an olympic high dive with your eyes open.

2 weeks later the boat sank tied to a dock...
 
Skuza, yes, it was in the 400, and she did well to get us and herself through it without damage.

My shoulder was sore for days from near constant adjustments of the throttle. I had adjusted the windlass to prevent it letting go of the chain (which happens at the worst times). But I didn't lock the dogs on the fwd hatch. With thousands of gallons of Lake Huron slamming against it, I was really regretting not being prepared. It held, but I didn't need the extra stress of imagining what would happen if that hatch opened.

We also hadn't closed the companionway, and no-one would let go of the grabrails to close it. The carpet was wet 1/3 of the way into the salon from the waves leaking through the eisin. We had to go find the toaster. It had escaped from the galley cupboard and had made it's way into the corner of the midcabin berth.

The TV, subwoofer, DVD player etc had all jumped for freedom, but that's my fault. I've since secured that setup. BTW, I'm still looking forward to hearing details of your new TV installation.

I did a pretty good writeup on the TV install back in May/June. Its worked awesome. Not that I ever encounter weather like you describe it makes me wonder how the new TV would hold on its factory screw mounts. Its through bolted to the wall but I wonder if the stress of bouncing would rip them out of the rear panel. Does make me wonder if I used lock washers at least? If you want anymore info feel free to PM me!
 
Tell me you guys with the shirts. Did earning them give you a whole new outlook on boating and the advise you give?

Doug
 
Doug,

Good story and your point about knowing your boat is a good one. One of our rougher days involved Tobermory as well, in '97. My wife and I with our three kids and a cat aboard a 28' Carver. We left Port Elgin on a breezy morning. Halfway to The Tub my new radar picked up a big black blob three miles ahead. I realized the blob would move east so we went twenty miles out and got into Tobermory after a pretty rough ride. The harbourmaster asked where we came from and said "see that dock? Stay there!" Turns out the blob was a tornado that later hit Wiarton. I've got a great picture of our cat barfing over the side. I think Lake Huron (and North Channel) can throw some pretty hellacious weather at you.
 
The harbourmaster asked where we came from and said "see that dock? Stay there!"

Classic "Klaus"?!

I'm a pretty conservative guy when it comes to advice, so I don't think those experiences changed me much. I've had regrets each way. Two years ago, a good friend bought a used boat 200 miles away and wanted my help to bring her home. I declined, citing unpredictable spring weather, unknown boat etc. So he had her partially torn apart and placed on a truck which delivered her in a indescribably-filthy condition, 2 weeks late and over budget. Live and learn - would've been a fun trip.
 
I am pretty conservative also. I started boating young and I took chances I wouldn't take now. I wasn't really frightened and I had been tempered several times but I never made that trip again. A trip I had made several times. I just don't want to ever experience a trip like that again. Follow the Michigan coast back and eliminate all that open water.
I have got into some serious discussions with people advising someone to move a new boat home. Some that would require some open ocean on a new to them boat and they were quite new to boating.
I remember one telling them it would be a trip of a lifetime.
Ya it might be just that.
You can easily get in over your head (pun kinda intended) quickly when you venture out without knowing yourself and your boat.
A couple of guys who had boats a while but no open water experience went to help a newby bring his boat home.
They later admitted they thought they were not going to make it.
Another factor is you don't want to scare a new Admiral.
That can end your boating before it really gets started.
Doug
 
Last edited:
I've never had any big water experience nor do I think I ever will. All mine has been local inland lakes. How ever the most frightening thing was 4th of July on Lake Martin. We decided to go watch the fire works show and this was just before Aqulapaloza so there were many many more boats on the lake than normal. And on top of that very large boats that had been trucked in for the show. My dad and I anchored out about 3 miles from the show thinking we would be out of the throng of boats. Just before the show started there were hundreds of boats around us. All drifting some times within feet. All was well and it was a good show fireworks show. As soon as the show was over, every light on the lake turned red "Port Side to us" and hundreds of boats started going the same way at the same time large and small.
The wake that hit us was so violent and so sudden we were getting lifted off the deck. I was in a small 21' cabin boat and it starts pitching and rolling in 6 to 7 foot wake.... Wake now, from the cumulative passage of all the boats at once . and short short chop...Man I though it was over. I got dad's life jacket on him,"He had a stroke yeas ago and can't fend for himself" and I put mine on and I had resigned my self to the lose of the boat and swim him to shore if that is what it came to. Some how,, and I think by the grace of God we got into a cove till it was all over and the boats had passed. Then some stupid kids started shooting bottle rockets at us not knowing how on edge I was. I was so on the edge. It took all my restraint to keep from responding with my 45ACP. Long story short. It's no where as big as your events. But to me, it was just as traumatic. It made me have a much larger view of my environment when on the water. It never occurred to me when we took that spot they would all take off at the same time...................
 
Hi Doug, yes rough weather boat handling will make you respect mother nature. It'll keep you humble.
I took these pics on my trip to the Abacos, Bahamas this past summer. I did these in a sundancer 240da. Like you said, good advise to know your boat, and how it will handle in rough weather. A 25 foot boat gets real small when you face these.

That's my cousins 30 foot Regal.
11111.jpg

333.jpg

222.jpg
 
Last edited:
WOW, that had to be a hairy ride. What size swells are those?

Hi Doug, yes rough weather boat handling will make you respect mother nature. It'll keep you humble.
I took these pics on my trip to the Abacos, Bahamas this past summer. I did these in a sundancer 240da. Like you said, good advise to know your boat, and how it will handle in rough weather. A 25 foot boat gets real small when you face these.

That's my cousins 30 foot Regal.
11111.jpg

333.jpg

222.jpg
 

Forum statistics

Threads
113,229
Messages
1,428,970
Members
61,117
Latest member
jingenio
Back
Top