Complications!

TMK988

New Member
Sep 17, 2009
118
Lloyd Harbor, NY
Boat Info
290 Sundancer 2006
Engines
Mercruiser
I really need the collective wisdom you guys afford here, I'll try to be suscinct. While I have had my first year as a boater under my belt and have learned much (alot if that wisdom having come from you all), I have a situation. My boat is a '06 290 with 150 hours on it. I treat it with great respect. My mechanic I have though was terrific, you all will have to help me out with that perception. He had my boat at his yard all winter. My insurance company paid him $10k after my boat got loose from the mooring and gently ended on the beach. There was no visible damage (other than some fiberglass issues which were addressed with a fiberglass guy for another $10!). Still, he dismantled the outdrives (Bravo 3's) and I guess straigtened out what ever was problamatic down there. Being a novice, I could be wrong, but I really don't know if, other that realinging stuff, that there was much wrong there. He did charge me an extra $1200 to replace the starboard side boot as he found some rust in that area. Well, the boat was splashed yesterday, he left it at his slip and I had to collect it and bring it around about 8 miles to my mooring. The deep scratch on my pristine blue hull that was not there when I checked the boat before it left his yard (where I buffed and waxed it) is the least of the issues. I am already getting wordy here as I am a little emotional about this mess so I will make this short. The port side engine is overheating terribly (when we had a discussion about the manifolds, he said that there is no indication that they need replacement yet), the starboard side engine only gets up to 102 degrees, I was getting a warning (other than the overheating engine warning... I limped home on one engine) that may have been the CO. detector (the cabin door was open and a few times during the trip I stopped and opened the bilge) and there is way more water in, what had been a very dry bilge than I have seen since I figured out that I can't wash the cockpit with a hose! My mechanic suggested, when I emailed him, that: I have 'knee capped' him by not just letting him do what ever he wants with the boat (I did tell him this year that I needed to keep costs down, but when he told me that I needed that new boot, I said yes immediately, I have always defered to him if there are things that are of import), that I may need a tuneup on the engines (would the need for a tuneup cause the engines to run hot/cold) and that if I am getting water in the bilge (this may have just gotten in there during the spashing, I will go down to the boat shortly to see if it is still afloat!) and that I should bring it to a marina and have it hauled because he is having a baby and is busy. I kind of felt that if a mechanic has taken off the outdrives that if there is a leak, that certainly would be the first possible reason. I need to qualify that I have been horribly gracious to this buy, have let him work on my boat after he is done with everyone else, have paid him not just promptly, but early! Well, I am sorry for the length of this and I guess I really needed to vent, I don't really think there is much you fellas can say to me here but to suck it up! Splash day hasn't really been all that much fun...
 
Quote:

My mechanic I have though was terrific, you all will have to help me out with that perception. He had my boat at his yard all winter. My insurance company paid him $10k after my boat got loose from the mooring and gently ended on the beach. There was no visible damage (other than some fiberglass issues which were addressed with a fiberglass guy for another $10!...................



What did your mechanic do for 10k??? and another $10 what??? grand???

I Feel bad for you...I hope it all works out....:smt009
 
My God man.....throw in a paragraph here and there.
 
My God man.....throw in a paragraph here and there.


+1 Got a headache reading it....But feel bad just the same....
 
Sorry fellas, a paragraph really would have been a good idea. I just want to qualify, there was '$10k' for mechanical issues with the outdrives and the same for the damage to the spline. When I saw the boat sitting on the beach it really looked just fine. I do recognize that there were some unseen problems, however, I am going to request a full accounting of the money charged by the mechanic.
 
Sorry fellas, a paragraph really would have been a good idea. I just want to qualify, there was '$10k' for mechanical issues with the outdrives and the same for the damage to the spline. When I saw the boat sitting on the beach it really looked just fine. I do recognize that there were some unseen problems, however, I am going to request a full accounting of the money charged by the mechanic.


Any before pics of the damaged fiberglass????
 
20,000.00......for a "soft" landing? Where is this 20k? Why didn't YOU get the check, it was from YOUR ins. co. right? I think you need to put in a call to your ins. co and get all the info from them. If it was HIS ins. co. I would still call my ins. co. to run this by them. I think he made a LOT of money on this claim if it was indeed a soft landing, and I think he is responsible to have everything repaired relating to the claim. Him having a baby has nothing to do with your boat not being operable( or maybe it does financially) and you have to stop being mister nice guy and do your due diligence
 
I'm sorry to say but at first read it sounds like this guy is taking advantage of your good nature. I would get a full accounting of what was damaged/repaired. I believe that you should have received your boat back in the condition it was prior to the grounding. The fact that the guy immediately blamed you for "knee capping" him sends up a red flag for me and quite frankly I would call " Bullsh!t!" on. A reputable person would hear your concerns and investigate before trying to assign blame. I know I have read on this board marinas acknowledging work not performed that was paid for and making amends immediately. This story sounds all too familiar of the fly by night "A-holes" that fleece their clients until they wise-up then try and make them feel guilty for questioning their shabby workmanship........I hope I am wrong for your sake.
 
Last edited:

Forum statistics

Threads
113,238
Messages
1,429,059
Members
61,119
Latest member
KenBoat
Back
Top