Shower sump box options

[b_arrington]

Has anyone had better luck with another brand of sump box vs. the OEM Rule box? I've seen a couple from Johnson, SeaFlo and Attwood. The SeaFlo one looks interesting because the lid snaps on vs. screws on. Unscrewing the lid to clean the screen is always a PITA.

My Rule sump box under my steps has broken. The internals are working ok, but the L-shaped tab off the box that attaches to the floor has cracked off so the box kind of flops around. I think this is the 2nd or 3rd replacement for various failures.

 

[j98052]

I replaced my graywater tank with a graywater tank and pump from Whaler. Works great, much better designed. The tank on my boat is larger than the Rule (had one on my previous Sundancer), but Whaler makes a variety of sizes.

 

[bc225]

The whale sump with the outside pump is what i installed on my 460 sundancer. The electronic float curred the constant problems with the oem. I acquired mine from defender install was easy. Have not had any issues in three years.