Reputation system poll – keep it or dump it

Reputation - Take it or leave it?

  • I like it!

    Votes: 12 14.6%
  • I hate it!

    Votes: 14 17.1%
  • I could care less!

    Votes: 56 68.3%

  • Total voters
    82
I said I would give this system a chance to work before I judge it and I will (even though mine is turned off :grin:).

It is interesting though to look at our member list sorted by total posts to see what the ratings are. So far you can't tell much because we just started this system but that's what I will look at in the future for a quick capsule of where the most active participants stand.:thumbsup:

http://clubsearay.com/forum/memberlist.php?&order=DESC&sort=posts&pp=30
 
OK...so to keep things fair, the next two people who register and post MUST receive negative feedback immediately.
 
OK...so to keep things fair, the next two people who register and post MUST receive negative feedback immediately.

:lol: Great idea~ Actually everyone should be red to begin with!
 
I said I would give this system a chance to work before I judge it and I will (even though mine is turned off :grin:).

It is interesting though to look at our member list sorted by total posts to see what the ratings are. So far you can't tell much because we just started this system but that's what I will look at in the future for a quick capsule of where the most active participants stand.:thumbsup:

http://clubsearay.com/forum/memberlist.php?&order=DESC&sort=posts&pp=30

Two members now have red dots

http://clubsearay.com/forum/memberlist.php?do=getall&pp=30&order=desc&sort=reputation&page=121

One I understand. The other I must have missed something.
 
Last edited:
My vote is to keep it. Heck I have even collected some points. :grin:
 
replace the red dot with a donut on the head

02030001-s.JPG
 
maybe use this one for a fast riser in the rankings

02250016-s.JPG
 
I cant believe I just read 6 pages on this thread and 14 on the other of this useless crap. When I first saw a green dot I thought it meant that member was signed in. At least thats what I wish it meant, that would be better than having to go to the forums page to see whos online. But then again, I could really care less what it means. SB
 
instead of 2 green dots, would could have a double muffin bunny ranking

twins.jpg
 
I cant believe I just read 6 pages on this thread and 14 on the other of this useless crap. When I first saw a green dot I thought it meant that member was signed in. At least thats what I wish it meant, that would be better than having to go to the forums page to see whos online. But then again, I could really care less what it means. SB

hijack alert
The little cloud next to the user names tells you if they are signed on or not.

Maybe something useful will come out of this thread:grin:
 
Members with 0 post offers great advice......
Members with hundreds of post gray dot......

:huh:

Is that correct?

Peter
 
I think the fact that several "1 post" and "0 post" members with green dots is a problem. Hopefully, our friendly moderators and admins can tweak that problem away. Haven't quite found the red dot people yet. . .but I haven't looked too hard either.
 
hijack alert
The little cloud next to the user names tells you if they are signed on or not.

Maybe something useful will come out of this thread:grin:

A cloud :huh: Whooda thunk it. I guess I'll give you another approval or whatever it is for letting me know. SB
 
I think it is pretty safe to say any red dot person is going to make their dot invisible. Give it time, if you don't like the way it is currently done go ahead and turn yours off until we get it to a point where it is not the only thing we talk about all day.

Wesley
 
Yeah, and two new members with 1 post each have ratings that say "XXX Offers Great Advice"
A perfect illustration as to the validity of the system.
I agree. What's the sense. At this rate EVERYONE will be green in 2 weeks.. then what? Who has more green boxes? Bad idea.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
112,950
Messages
1,422,857
Members
60,932
Latest member
juliediane
Back
Top